Remember film guys, do you. You just shot things underexposed and it still looked great. Remember how all the colours and exposure smoothly bled into each other when you shot 5217. Blacks were blacks, whites were not overexposed but just a part of the image.
Point being, people complain because digital still don't do it right! I downloaded the original file, and I just won't be buying any camera. To my eye, I could get these results with GH2 at a lower ISO and by adding more light. Sure, there would be more banding and noise, but when it is at this level I find it distracting and why not add more of it. If you want to know what irks me most about the image, it's the undulating banding on her finger tips, possibly from the light of a flame swaying in the faintest breeze. Sure, it's great to capture this detail, but the codec just kinda hands it back to us in a distracting way.
Some of the later shots look great. They remind me of something from the 70s, maybe Altman using pre-flashed film. This is the real crime, that some results make me forget it's digital, and then other shots make me wonder if it is an i-phone? This is the newest challenge to being a DP, so many different cameras and each with their niche. I think this camera has a vast potential for some projects, but you need to know that limit. It's scary now getting called in for a job and they say they are using yadda yadda whatever camera and you haven't used it and you don't really know the limits. You know of course, 8 or 10 bit, what codec, the workflow, but you can't say for sure how she'll ride. If it's a real job they let you take her out and play, but most jobs aren't this professional and the whole shoot will put you in the hot seat.
Some people have commented that this is a better demo video for the camera. This is true, I am sick of landscape camera tests. How many times are we working for any kind of job and the shot came down to a landscape and the dynamic range. I don't think hardly any audience anywhere gave a flip about the dynamic range in the films landscape shot. What, maybe the shot in NO Country for Old Men needed that range for artistic flare, but seriously, most videos I shoot it's about the actors face or clarity of image during events. Test videos need to shoot real light situations (including what you would pull from your grip truck) and people's faces. PEOPLE!!! Cameras do more than landscapes and if you are going to buy a camera, that's why you need to pick the most flexible one.