Jump to content

SD-Card Benchmark (with Samsung tool in DEV mode)

derderimmermuedeist

By derderimmermuedeist,
In: Cameras

 Share
Followers 0

Recommended Posts

derderimmermuedeist Member

derderimmermuedeist

Posted
  • Author
Posted
5 hours ago, Marco Tecno said:

Actually you didn't get my point. I own both samsung pro and lexar 2000x cards. The real world difference (not benchmark) is of the 4-5x magnitude. Hence there is something wrong with that benchmark.

http://www.cameramemoryspeed.com/samsung-nx1/sd-card-comparison/

You can read at the end of the Page in the "Samsung NX1 Performance Analysis":

"Although the NX1 supports the UHS-II interface, using UHS-II cards did not result in significantly faster write speed. In these tests the camera averaged up to 60 MB/s write speed with the fastest cards during continuous shooting. This is somewhat of a disappointment given the potential of UHS-II speed. The NX1 is otherwise a very fast and capable camera."

Link to comment
Share on other sites
EOSHD Pro Color 5 for Sony cameras EOSHD Z LOG for Nikon CamerasEOSHD C-LOG and Film Profiles for All Canon DSLRs
  • Replies 50
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

derderimmermuedeist
derderimmermuedeist

I thought that we could make a Database here: Samsung NX1:  68.374 KB/s  Lexar SDXC 64 GB UHS-II U3 / Class 10  50.740 KB/s  ScanDisk SDHC 8 GB UHS-I / Class 10  44.328 KB/s  

Marco Tecno
Marco Tecno

Actually you didn't get my point. I own both samsung pro and lexar 2000x cards. The real world difference (not benchmark) is of the 4-5x magnitude. Hence there is something wrong with that benchmark.

Pavel Mašek
Pavel Mašek

I think it depends on type of benchmark - even if you test it on PC: Kingston Mobilelite G4 USB3 UHSII reader Sandisk 64GB UHS-I Extrem PRO 95M/s R/W  USBDeview - 42MBs / 92MBs

Posted Images

Marco Tecno Long-time member

Marco Tecno

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, derderimmermuedeist said:

http://www.cameramemoryspeed.com/samsung-nx1/sd-card-comparison/

You can read at the end of the Page in the "Samsung NX1 Performance Analysis":

"Although the NX1 supports the UHS-II interface, using UHS-II cards did not result in significantly faster write speed. In these tests the camera averaged up to 60 MB/s write speed with the fastest cards during continuous shooting. This is somewhat of a disappointment given the potential of UHS-II speed. The NX1 is otherwise a very fast and capable camera."

I think I already made my point three times about that test. With fw 1.4, the writing speed to sd increased considerably. Based on that test, I had bought the samsung pro card. After fw 1.4 came, I bought the lexar 2000x and wow, such a huge difference.

 

I sent several emails to that site asking to retest, but they replied they hadn't got the nx1 anymore. So no new test. But they should at least add a disclaimer about reports from users about 4x higher speeds with fw 1.4.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Pavel Mašek Active member

Pavel Mašek

Posted
Posted

I think it depends on type of benchmark - even if you test it on PC:

Kingston Mobilelite G4 USB3 UHSII reader

Sandisk 64GB UHS-I Extrem PRO 95M/s

R/W 

USBDeview - 42MBs / 92MBs

SpeedOut v 0.5  - 85MBs / 88MBs

USB Flash Benchmark - max. 91MBs / 92Mbs

BTW - I have received my cheap Lexar 2000x 64GB UHSII ( http://www.ebay.com/itm/181946939074?_trksid=p2060353.m2749.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT ) . It is little bit suspicious as Lexar brand is taped up by some Chinese holografic signs. But I have test it and seems to be OK.

NX1 - average around 66MBs / 88 MBs

USBDeview - 67MBs / 220MBs

SpeedOut v 0.5  - around 220MBs / around 220MBs (here is limit USB reader)

USB Flash Benchmark (it depends on file size) - max. 220MBs / 220Mbs (here is limit USB reader)

I simply do not trust NX1 benchmark - camera definitely writes faster according what I have already tested with burst shots.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
derderimmermuedeist Member

derderimmermuedeist

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Samsung NX1:

  1.  68.374 KB/s  Lexar Professional 2000x SDXC  64GB UHS-II U3 /Class 10 [300 MB/s]
  2.  60.000 KB/s  Transcend Ultimate           SDXC  64GB UHS-II U3 /Class 10 [180 MB/s]*
  3.  53.605 KB/s  SanDisk Extreme Pro        SDXC  64GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  90 MB/s]
  4.  50.740 KB/s  SanDisk Extreme Pro        SDHC    8GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  90 MB/s]
  5.  44.328 KB/s  Samsung Pro Plus            SDXC   64GB UHS-I U3 /Class 10 [  90 MB/s]
  6.  37.873 KB/s  Transcend Extreme R95   SDXC   64GB UHS-I U3 /Class 10 [  85 MB/s]
  7.  37.347 KB/s  SanDisk                            SDHC     8GB UHS-I      /Class 10 [  45 MB/s]
  8.  36.186 KB/s  Samsung Pro          microSDHC   16GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  50 MB/s]
  9.  34.880 KB/s  Lexar Professional 400x  SDXC 128GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  10 MB/s]
  10.  29.183 KB/s  Lexar Professional 400x  SDXC   64GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  10 MB/s]
  11.  29.078 KB/s  Samsung Pro MB-SGCGB SDXC  64GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  40 MB/s]
  12.  18.217 KB/s  Transcend                         SDHC  32GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  20 MB/s]
  13.  16.616 KB/s  ADATA                               SDHC  32GB                 /Class  06 [    6 MB/s]
  14.  12.772 KB/s  SanDisk Ultra          microSDHC  16GB                 /Class 10
  15.    3.735 KB/s  Transcend                         SDHC    4GB                 /Class 04
  16.  ??.???

* Camera freezes after each test

Link to comment
Share on other sites
tugela Frequent member

tugela

Posted
Posted
On ‎4‎/‎1‎/‎2016 at 7:19 AM, derderimmermuedeist said:

http://www.cameramemoryspeed.com/samsung-nx1/sd-card-comparison/

You can read at the end of the Page in the "Samsung NX1 Performance Analysis":

"Although the NX1 supports the UHS-II interface, using UHS-II cards did not result in significantly faster write speed. In these tests the camera averaged up to 60 MB/s write speed with the fastest cards during continuous shooting. This is somewhat of a disappointment given the potential of UHS-II speed. The NX1 is otherwise a very fast and capable camera."

The methodology they used is flawed however. They recorded the write light and made the assumption that recording was taking place continuously while it was flashing. If it was not continuous then the actual write speed would have been a lot higher.

If most of the "flashing light" time was actually processing, then later firmware updates may well have made that more efficient with the net result being that the overall apparent write time was much faster even thought the actual write times remained the same.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
MountneerMan Active member

MountneerMan

Posted
Posted

Lexar 1000x(150MB/sec) UHS-II/U3 cards on sale at amazon.com

64GB = $29.99 USD
128GB = $52.99 USD

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00PLENZX4/ref=br_prlt_slcty_pdt-10?ie=UTF8&smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_s=merchandised-search-3&pf_rd_r=0WHJXHT98R1W3RT5CYSW&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=ba792081-312d-47cf-afaf-a77290723514&pf_rd_i=13431004011

Link to comment
Share on other sites
derderimmermuedeist Member

derderimmermuedeist

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Samsung NX1:

  1.  68.374 KB/s  Lexar Professional 2000x SDXC  64GB UHS-II U3 /Class 10 [300 MB/s]
  2.  60.000 KB/s  Transcend Ultimate           SDXC  64GB UHS-II U3 /Class 10 [180 MB/s]*
  3.  50.740 KB/s  SanDisk Extreme Pro        SDHC    8GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  90 MB/s]
  4.  53.710 KB/s  SanDisk Extreme Pro        SDXC  64GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  90 MB/s]
  5.  44.328 KB/s  Samsung Pro                    SDXC   64GB UHS-I       
  6.  37.873 KB/s  Transcend                         SDXC   64GB UHS-I U3
  7.  37.347 KB/s  SanDisk                            SDHC     8GB UHS-I
  8.  36.186 KB/s  Samsung Pro          microSDHC   16GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  9.  35.106 KB/s  Transcend                         SDXC   64GB UHS-I U3 /Class 10
  10.  34.880 KB/s  Lexar Professional 400x  SDXC 128GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  11.  32.615 KB/s  Kingston                           SDXC 128GB UHS-I U3 /Class10
  12.  29.183 KB/s  Lexar Professional 400x  SDXC   64GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  13.  29.078 KB/s  Samsung Pro MB-SGCGB SDXC  64GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  14.  18.217 KB/s  Transcend                         SDHC  32GB                 /Class 10
  15.  16.616 KB/s  ADATA                               SDHC  32GB                 /Class 06
  16.  12.772 KB/s  SanDisk Ultra          microSDHC  16GB                 /Class 10
  17.    3.735 KB/s  Transcend                         SDHC    4GB                 /Class 04
  18.  ??.???

* Camera freezes after each test

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...
SR Frequent member

SR

Posted
Posted
5 hours ago, Marco Tecno said:

Sr, not sure about those results. Seems like the benchmark is somewhat flawed, since I get about 4x performance with a lexar 2000x compared to a samsung pro (when buffer full...5-6fps vs 1-1.5fps).

Thanks! Was worried about it not being "hack-proof", especially for the new higher bitrate video files.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 3 weeks later...
derderimmermuedeist Member

derderimmermuedeist

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Samsung NX1:

  1.  68.374 KB/s  Lexar Professional 2000x SDXC  64GB UHS-II U3 /Class 10 [300 MB/s]
  2.  60.000 KB/s  Transcend Ultimate           SDXC  64GB UHS-II U3 /Class 10 [180 MB/s]*
  3.  50.740 KB/s  SanDisk Extreme Pro        SDHC    8GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  90 MB/s]
  4.  53.710 KB/s  SanDisk Extreme Pro        SDXC  64GB UHS-I       /Class 10 [  90 MB/s]
  5.  44.328 KB/s  Samsung Pro                    SDXC   64GB UHS-I       
  6.  37.873 KB/s  Transcend                         SDXC   64GB UHS-I U3
  7.  37.347 KB/s  SanDisk                            SDHC     8GB UHS-I
  8.  36.186 KB/s  Samsung Pro          microSDHC   16GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  9.  35.106 KB/s  Transcend                         SDXC   64GB UHS-I U3 /Class 10
  10.  34.880 KB/s  Lexar Professional 400x  SDXC 128GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  11.  33.727 KB/s  Intenso Professional        SDXC   64GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  12.  32.615 KB/s  Kingston                           SDXC 128GB UHS-I U3 /Class 10
  13.  29.183 KB/s  Lexar Professional 400x  SDXC   64GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  14.  29.078 KB/s  Samsung Pro MB-SGCGB SDXC  64GB UHS-I       /Class 10
  15.  18.217 KB/s  Transcend                         SDHC  32GB                 /Class 10
  16.  16.616 KB/s  ADATA                               SDHC  32GB                 /Class 06
  17.  12.772 KB/s  SanDisk Ultra          microSDHC  16GB                 /Class 10
  18.    3.735 KB/s  Transcend                         SDHC    4GB                 /Class 04
  19.  ??.???

* Camera freezes after each test

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 4 weeks later...
tugela Frequent member

tugela

Posted
Posted

Write speed specs change depending on the size of memory available on the card even within a particular brand/model.

the Lexar Professional 633x cards for example have write specs of 10 MB/s for the 16GB card, 20 MB/s for the 32-128GB cards, and 40 MB/s for the 256-512GB cards. Likewise for 1000X UHS-II cards, which range from 40-80 MB/s depending on the memory size.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Parker Frequent member

Parker

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, Herb said:

Asked it the petition thread... I need a QUICK answer so I can overnight a card from Amazon. What card are you using to record 180mbps reliably? 

I use the lexar 2000x uhs-ii card (64 GB) all the time at 200+ Mbps without any issues. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Followers 0
Go to topic listing
  • EOSHD Pro Color 5 for All Sony cameras
    EOSHD C-LOG and Film Profiles for All Canon DSLRs
    EOSHD Dynamic Range Enhancer for H.264/H.265
×
×
  • Create New...